Jen pro úplnost.
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/Lex ... 031:CS:PDF
a:I completely agree
b:I agree
c: I disagree
1. other - political party
2. Czech Republic
3. Česká pirátská strana, U Botiče 1390/3 ,140 00 Praha 4,
info@pirati.cz
4. ano
5. * Content facilitating phishing, pharming or hacking.
* Incitement to hatred or violence (on the basis of race, religion, gender, sexual orientation etc.)
* Child abuse content
* Terrorism related content (e.g. content inciting the commitment of terrorist offences and training material)
* Defamation
* Privacy infringements
Tzn zaškrtl bych hvězdičky - jelikož si myslím, že tyto kategorie jsou společensky více nebezpečné.
6. To what extent do you agree with the following statements on notice-and-action procedures?
Action against illegal content is often ineffective* c
Action against illegal content is often too slow* c
Hosting service providers often take action against content legal * a
There is too much legal fragmentation and uncertainty for hosting service providers and notice providers* a
7. To what extent do you agree with the following statements on Article 14 of the E-commerce Directive?
The exact scope of 'hosting' is sufficiently clear* b
The terms “actual knowledge” and “awareness” are sufficiently clear* b
The term “expeditiously” is sufficiently clear* c
8. In your opinion, what activities should be considered as 'hosting'?*
Social networks
Blogs and interactive dictionaries
Video-sharing sites
Cloud based services
E-commerce platforms
Souhlasím s tou vyhláškou
9.
It is easy to find pages or tools to notify illegal content* a
It is easy to use pages or tools to notify illegal content* a
10. Should all hosting service providers have a procedure in place which allows them to be easily notified of illegal
content that they may be hosting?* yes
Je třeba efektivně a jednoduše odstranit či znepřístupnit nelegální obsah (nebezpečí zřejmé jako dětská prostituce etc.)
11. If a hosting service provider has a procedure for notifying illegal content (such as a web form designed for that
purpose) that is easy to find and easy to use, should illegal content exclusively be notified by means of that
procedure?* yes
Jednoduše si myslím, že by mělo dojít k co nejrychlejší reakci ze strany poskytovatele služby na uživatele, který daný obsah nahrál a poté, co tento odmítne obsah smazat/obhájit
jeho legálnost, obsah by měl být znepřístupněn a dále prozkoumán. V případě, že se prokáže jeho skutečná nelegálnost, postupoval bych dle směrnice EU. (viz postup dole)
12.
A notice should be submitted by electronic means * yes
A notice should contain contact details of the sender * yes
A notice should make it easy to identify the alleged illegal content (for instance by providing a URL) * yes
A notice should contain a detailed description of the alleged illegal nature ofthe content * yes
A notice should contain evidence that the content provider could not be contacted before contacting the hosting service provider or that the content provider was
contacted first but did not act * yes
13. Should there be rules to avoid unjustified notifications? yes
Nemělo by docházet k zneužívání této služby podobně, jako je tomu u např. policie.
14. How can unjustified notifications be best prevented?*
By providing for sanctions against abusive notices
Nejednoduší řešení se zdá ban na nick+ip při opakovaném falešném nahlášení u dané služby.
15. Should hosting service providers provide feedback to notice providers about the status of their notice?*
Yes
The hosting service provider should send a confirmation of receipt.
The hosting service provider should inform the notice provider of any action that is taken.
Přijde mi slušné dostat vyrozumění o tom, že poskytovatel služby odbdržel moje oznámení a taktéž mi přijde normální informovat o průběhu a ukončení mé stížnosti.
16. Should hosting service providers consult the providers of alleged illegal content? yes
Upon reception of a notice, but before any action on the alleged illegal content is taken. This would avoid the
disabling of legal content or it been taken down.
Podle mě se tímto přístupem dá minimalizovat náhodné, či nespravedlivé smazání legálního obsahu.
17. Assuming that certain content is illegal, how should a hosting service provider act? *
The hosting service provider should first disable access to the illegal content
Daný obsah, respektive informace v něm obsažené mohou být důležité z hlediska případného trestního stíhání.
18. When the same item of illegal content is hosted by several providers, which hosting service provider should act
against it? *
other opinion:
The hosting service provider that is aware of the illegal content, but is not technically in a position to remove
that illegal content and would for instance have to take down an entire site. Bud can disable it.
19. Once a hosting service provider becomes aware of illegal content, how fast should it act? *
As fast as possible depending on the concrete circumstances of the case
20. Should hosting service providers act expeditiously on illegal content, even when there is a request from law
enforcement authorities not to do so? *
not opinion. shoud be judged case to case.
obecně vzato ano, například dětské porno etc.
21. How can unjustified action against legal content be best addressed/prevented?*
By consulting the content provider before any action is taken
By providing easy and accessible appeal procedures
By providing for sanctions against abusive notices
22. In your opinion, should hosting service providers be protected against liability that could result from taking
pro-active measures? * NO
Myslím, že to povede k větší opatrnosti poskytovatelů, kteří budou nuceni jednat korektně
23. Should the EU play a role in contributing to the functioning of N&A procedures?*
Yes - By encouraging self-regulation
Obecně si myslím, že jakákoliv regulace internetu je špatná.
24. Do you consider that different categories of illegal content require different policy approaches as regards
notice-and-action procedures?*
Yes
znova. dětská pornografie a uploadnutý film jsou dva naprosto odlišné činy.